What Was on Dimmesdale's Chest? The Scarlet Letter’s Darkest Mystery

The Enigma at the Heart of Hawthorne’s Tale

So, let’s get into it — seriously, what was on Reverend Arthur Dimmesdale’s chest? If you’ve read The Scarlet Letter (or even skimmed it in school), you probably remember that moment near the end when he bares his chest before the crowd... and everyone reacts like they’ve just seen a ghost. Nathaniel Hawthorne, that sneaky devil, never directly tells us. Instead, we get hints, rumors, contradictions. Gah! It's both genius and frustrating.

Theories About Dimmesdale’s Chest

A Physical Scarlet Letter?

One major theory (maybe the most popular) is that Dimmesdale literally branded or carved the letter “A” into his chest. Oof. The idea is that he was so wracked with guilt over his secret sin — fathering a child with Hester — that he physically punished himself.

There’s textual evidence pointing this way. Chillingworth, his tormentor, seems to see something on his chest. The townspeople gossip about it. Dimmesdale is often seen clutching his chest in agony. So yeah, it fits. But is it definitive? Nope.

A Supernatural Mark?

Others say it wasn’t self-inflicted, but rather a kind of divine punishment. A supernatural manifestation of his guilt — kind of like how Hester has to wear the scarlet A on her clothes, but his appeared on his skin.

This version fits with Hawthorne’s themes of Puritanism, sin, and public shame. God saw his hidden sin and left a mark. Sounds a bit extreme, but hey, it was Puritan New England. Everything was fire, brimstone, and secret guilt.

Psychological Projection?

Wait, here’s a curveball: what if there was nothing on his chest? What if it was just a metaphor?

This theory is for the lit nerds. Maybe all that talk about his chest pain, the “mark,” the gasping crowd — it’s Hawthorne showing us how guilt eats a person alive. The mark doesn’t have to be real; it’s an outward symbol of his inner torment. Honestly, that’s kind of beautiful (and sad as hell).

What Do the Witnesses Say?

Chillingworth’s Reaction

When Dimmesdale reveals his chest at the end, Chillingworth yells something like “Thou hast escaped me!” That seems like a big clue. It’s as if Chillingworth’s whole thing — manipulating Dimmesdale’s guilt — depended on keeping that sin secret. So when it’s exposed, even symbolically, Dimmesdale is free.

But... again, we don’t get a clear image of what’s revealed. Hawthorne loves ambiguity.

The Townspeople's Take

Here’s where it gets juicy. Hawthorne writes that different people saw different things. Some swore they saw a scarlet letter, just like Hester’s. Others said there was nothing there — just the weight of sin. So we’re left asking: was it even meant to be solved?

Classic Hawthorne. He gives us all the puzzle pieces but refuses to confirm if it’s even a puzzle.

Hawthorne’s Intent: Mystery as Moral Message

Let’s not forget the guy behind all this literary chaos: Nathaniel Hawthorne. The dude was obsessed with ambiguity. In The Scarlet Letter, he constantly blurs the line between the physical and the symbolic, between what’s seen and what’s imagined.

Maybe Dimmesdale’s chest wound is supposed to stay mysterious. Maybe Hawthorne wanted us to feel the same confusion, the same torment of uncertainty, that Dimmesdale did.

Or maybe he just liked messing with his readers (he probably did, to be fair).

Bottom line:

• The mark on Dimmesdale’s chest? Could be a real scarlet A, a supernatural punishment, or just a metaphor for crushing guilt.

• Hawthorne refuses to give a clear answer — and maybe that’s the point.

• Whatever was there (or not there), it devastated Dimmesdale and shocked the crowd.

And yeah, part of me still wishes Hawthorne had just said, “Yup, it was a big red A.” But then again... it wouldn’t be half as haunting if he had.

Is 165 cm normal for a 15 year old?

The predicted height for a female, based on your parents heights, is 155 to 165cm. Most 15 year old girls are nearly done growing. I was too. It's a very normal height for a girl.

Is 160 cm too tall for a 12 year old?

How Tall Should a 12 Year Old Be? We can only speak to national average heights here in North America, whereby, a 12 year old girl would be between 137 cm to 162 cm tall (4-1/2 to 5-1/3 feet). A 12 year old boy should be between 137 cm to 160 cm tall (4-1/2 to 5-1/4 feet).

How tall is a average 15 year old?

Average Height to Weight for Teenage Boys - 13 to 20 Years

How to get taller at 18?

Staying physically active is even more essential from childhood to grow and improve overall health. But taking it up even in adulthood can help you add a few inches to your height. Strength-building exercises, yoga, jumping rope, and biking all can help to increase your flexibility and grow a few inches taller.

Is 5.7 a good height for a 15 year old boy?

Generally speaking, the average height for 15 year olds girls is 62.9 inches (or 159.7 cm). On the other hand, teen boys at the age of 15 have a much higher average height, which is 67.0 inches (or 170.1 cm).

Can you grow between 16 and 18?

Most girls stop growing taller by age 14 or 15. However, after their early teenage growth spurt, boys continue gaining height at a gradual pace until around 18. Note that some kids will stop growing earlier and others may keep growing a year or two more.

Can you grow 1 cm after 17?

Even with a healthy diet, most people's height won't increase after age 18 to 20. The graph below shows the rate of growth from birth to age 20. As you can see, the growth lines fall to zero between ages 18 and 20 ( 7 , 8 ). The reason why your height stops increasing is your bones, specifically your growth plates.