What Are the Criticism of Machiavelli's The Prince?
The controversy behind the "ends justify the means" mantra
A blueprint for tyranny?
Let’s get the obvious out of the way first: The Prince has been accused, for centuries, of being a manual for ruthless power. Machiavelli’s advice—like using deceit, fear, or cruelty to maintain control—rubbed a lot of thinkers the wrong way. Critics say he glorifies manipulation, reducing leadership to a cynical game of control.
One of the most quoted lines, "It is better to be feared than loved, if you cannot be both,"… yeah, that’s not exactly warm and fuzzy.
Ethical criticisms: where’s the morality?
Morality gets sidelined... or maybe bulldozed
Philosophers like Erasmus and Montaigne pretty much lost it when they read Machiavelli. Why? Because The Prince doesn’t talk about justice, virtue (at least not in the usual Christian sense), or human dignity. It treats ethics like an optional extra, not the foundation of good leadership.
Critics say: He encourages leaders to lie, kill, and betray if it gets results.
Machiavelli might reply: Well, what matters is the survival of the state.
So you get this tension between realpolitik (cold, hard strategy) and traditional moral values. Is that leadership or just brute survivalism?
Religious backlash and early censorship
The Church was not amused
The Catholic Church actually put The Prince on the Index of Prohibited Books in 1559. Why? Because it promoted ideas that undermined divine right and Christian governance. Popes, bishops, theologians—they all saw Machiavelli as dangerous.
He didn’t just challenge religious authority; he removed it entirely from the political equation. That’s radical for a book written in the early 1500s.
Feminist and modern critiques
Gender? What gender?
Modern scholars point out how The Prince is exclusively male-centric. Leadership is always portrayed through male figures, metaphors are often martial or violent, and there's zero reflection on inclusion or softness as strength.
Also, in today’s world, where emotional intelligence, collaboration, and empathy are highly valued, Machiavelli’s version of leadership can feel—well—a bit medieval.
That said, some argue that The Prince isn't a prescription, but a description of how power already works. Still, the tone is brutally masculine.
Was it satire? Or are we reading it all wrong?
Wait—was he actually being ironic?
Here’s the twist. Some historians (especially in the 20th century) suggest that Machiavelli was actually writing satire. That he intended The Prince to be read as a warning, not a guide. He might’ve been exposing how absurd and brutal real politics had become.
This reading flips the whole narrative. Instead of being a monster, he becomes a critic—hiding his true message behind a mask of cold advice.
But honestly? No one can say for sure.
Conclusion: a book loved and loathed for the same reasons
The Prince is still one of the most controversial and debated political texts ever written. Critics say it’s immoral, manipulative, even evil. Supporters call it brutally honest, realistic, maybe even necessary.
The truth? Depends on how you read it—and what you believe politics is really for.
One thing’s clear: Machiavelli won’t stop making people argue any time soon.
How much height should a boy have to look attractive?
Well, fellas, worry no more, because a new study has revealed 5ft 8in is the ideal height for a man. Dating app Badoo has revealed the most right-swiped heights based on their users aged 18 to 30.
Is 172 cm good for a man?
Yes it is. Average height of male in India is 166.3 cm (i.e. 5 ft 5.5 inches) while for female it is 152.6 cm (i.e. 5 ft) approximately. So, as far as your question is concerned, aforesaid height is above average in both cases.
Is 165 cm normal for a 15 year old?
The predicted height for a female, based on your parents heights, is 155 to 165cm. Most 15 year old girls are nearly done growing. I was too. It's a very normal height for a girl.
Is 160 cm too tall for a 12 year old?
How Tall Should a 12 Year Old Be? We can only speak to national average heights here in North America, whereby, a 12 year old girl would be between 137 cm to 162 cm tall (4-1/2 to 5-1/3 feet). A 12 year old boy should be between 137 cm to 160 cm tall (4-1/2 to 5-1/4 feet).
How tall is a average 15 year old?
Average Height to Weight for Teenage Boys - 13 to 20 Years
| Male Teens: 13 - 20 Years) | ||
|---|---|---|
| 14 Years | 112.0 lb. (50.8 kg) | 64.5" (163.8 cm) |
| 15 Years | 123.5 lb. (56.02 kg) | 67.0" (170.1 cm) |
| 16 Years | 134.0 lb. (60.78 kg) | 68.3" (173.4 cm) |
| 17 Years | 142.0 lb. (64.41 kg) | 69.0" (175.2 cm) |
How to get taller at 18?
Staying physically active is even more essential from childhood to grow and improve overall health. But taking it up even in adulthood can help you add a few inches to your height. Strength-building exercises, yoga, jumping rope, and biking all can help to increase your flexibility and grow a few inches taller.
Is 5.7 a good height for a 15 year old boy?
Generally speaking, the average height for 15 year olds girls is 62.9 inches (or 159.7 cm). On the other hand, teen boys at the age of 15 have a much higher average height, which is 67.0 inches (or 170.1 cm).
Can you grow between 16 and 18?
Most girls stop growing taller by age 14 or 15. However, after their early teenage growth spurt, boys continue gaining height at a gradual pace until around 18. Note that some kids will stop growing earlier and others may keep growing a year or two more.
Can you grow 1 cm after 17?
Even with a healthy diet, most people's height won't increase after age 18 to 20. The graph below shows the rate of growth from birth to age 20. As you can see, the growth lines fall to zero between ages 18 and 20 ( 7 , 8 ). The reason why your height stops increasing is your bones, specifically your growth plates.