Why Didn’t Snape Fight McGonagall? Unraveling the Mystery

If you're a Harry Potter fan, you've probably wondered why, in the heat of battle, Severus Snape never fought Minerva McGonagall during the Battle of Hogwarts. There’s tension, rivalry, and history between these two characters, but Snape never directly duels McGonagall. Why? Was there more to this situation than just a simple conflict of interests? Let's dive into the complex layers of their relationship and the battle, and try to figure out why Snape didn’t raise his wand against McGonagall.

The Hidden Truth Behind Snape’s Loyalty to Dumbledore

At first glance, it seems like Snape and McGonagall should have clashed. After all, they were on opposite sides during the battle—McGonagall fighting for the Order of the Phoenix, and Snape, at that time, ostensibly fighting for Voldemort. But there’s something deeper at play. Snape was always loyal to Dumbledore, despite his outward behavior. This loyalty is what guided his actions, even when it appeared like he was betraying everyone at Hogwarts.

Snape’s Secret Mission for Dumbledore

One of the things that many fans might overlook is the extent of Snape’s commitment to Dumbledore’s plan. Snape’s role was far more complex than just a double agent. He wasn’t just playing a role to keep Voldemort’s trust; he was actively working to protect Harry Potter, all while maintaining his cover. If he had fought McGonagall, it could have exposed his true allegiance. In a way, Snape was protecting the greater good, which didn’t allow for personal vendettas, even against someone like McGonagall, who might have been one of his greatest adversaries.

The Respect Between Snape and McGonagall

Now, here’s where it gets a little more nuanced. Despite their differences, Snape and McGonagall shared a certain mutual respect. Sure, they bickered and had their differences—Snape was known for belittling McGonagall's more traditional, no-nonsense ways, while she often criticized him for his cruel and caustic methods. But beneath the surface, there was a respect for each other’s skills and roles at Hogwarts.

The Old School Connection

This respect may stem from their shared history at Hogwarts. Both were deeply involved in the running of the school, and they knew each other well enough to understand that fighting wouldn’t get them anywhere. It’s almost like a sibling rivalry—they both knew each other’s strengths and weaknesses. Snape respected McGonagall’s courage and loyalty, while McGonagall, despite her tough exterior, probably understood Snape’s deeper motivations. This unspoken understanding might have played a part in why Snape didn’t engage with her in combat.

Snape’s True Allegiance Was to Protect, Not to Conquer

If we look at the Battle of Hogwarts, Snape’s priority wasn’t to fight for Voldemort; it was to protect the students, the school, and ultimately, Harry Potter. His ultimate goal was the defeat of Voldemort, but he also had to do it in a way that kept his true intentions hidden. Fighting McGonagall, who was a key member of the opposition, might have compromised his long-term mission.

Snape’s Sacrifice for the Greater Good

One of the most moving aspects of Snape’s character is his ability to sacrifice for the greater good. He never let personal grudges interfere with his mission. Even if McGonagall had been on the front lines of the battle, Snape’s understanding of the greater purpose would have kept him from raising his wand against her. His battle was against Voldemort, not his colleagues.

The Psychological Strain of Snape’s Double Life

It’s also important to consider the toll that Snape’s double life took on him. By the time of the Battle of Hogwarts, Snape was exhausted from years of pretending to be something he wasn’t. His actions were driven by a desire to honor Dumbledore’s final requests and to protect the students he secretly cared about. In a sense, fighting McGonagall, someone who represented the school and Dumbledore’s legacy, would have been like fighting against everything he had worked for.

Snape’s Inner Conflict

I remember chatting with a friend about this, and we both agreed that Snape’s internal conflict was one of the biggest reasons he didn’t fight McGonagall. He was caught between two worlds, playing the villain in front of Voldemort while doing everything he could to protect those he cared about. If he had fought McGonagall, it would have been a step toward exposing his true nature, and he couldn’t risk that.

Conclusion: Snape’s Strength Was in His Restraint

At the end of the day, Snape’s strength lay in his restraint, his ability to stay focused on his mission, and his unwillingness to let personal conflict derail his long-term goals. He didn’t fight McGonagall because, despite their differences, they were ultimately on the same side when it came to the battle against Voldemort. It wasn’t a matter of avoiding her; it was about staying true to his mission of protecting the students and ensuring the ultimate defeat of the Dark Lord.

So, the next time you think about why Snape didn’t fight McGonagall, remember this: sometimes, the most powerful move is the one you don’t make.

Is 165 cm normal for a 15 year old?

The predicted height for a female, based on your parents heights, is 155 to 165cm. Most 15 year old girls are nearly done growing. I was too. It's a very normal height for a girl.

Is 160 cm too tall for a 12 year old?

How Tall Should a 12 Year Old Be? We can only speak to national average heights here in North America, whereby, a 12 year old girl would be between 137 cm to 162 cm tall (4-1/2 to 5-1/3 feet). A 12 year old boy should be between 137 cm to 160 cm tall (4-1/2 to 5-1/4 feet).

How tall is a average 15 year old?

Average Height to Weight for Teenage Boys - 13 to 20 Years

How to get taller at 18?

Staying physically active is even more essential from childhood to grow and improve overall health. But taking it up even in adulthood can help you add a few inches to your height. Strength-building exercises, yoga, jumping rope, and biking all can help to increase your flexibility and grow a few inches taller.

Is 5.7 a good height for a 15 year old boy?

Generally speaking, the average height for 15 year olds girls is 62.9 inches (or 159.7 cm). On the other hand, teen boys at the age of 15 have a much higher average height, which is 67.0 inches (or 170.1 cm).

Can you grow between 16 and 18?

Most girls stop growing taller by age 14 or 15. However, after their early teenage growth spurt, boys continue gaining height at a gradual pace until around 18. Note that some kids will stop growing earlier and others may keep growing a year or two more.

Can you grow 1 cm after 17?

Even with a healthy diet, most people's height won't increase after age 18 to 20. The graph below shows the rate of growth from birth to age 20. As you can see, the growth lines fall to zero between ages 18 and 20 ( 7 , 8 ). The reason why your height stops increasing is your bones, specifically your growth plates.